Over 5,000 Titles Banned from Texas Prisons

Beth Ayer is a graduate student in the Professional Writing program at UMass Dartmouth, and the web editor for Changing Lives, Changing Minds.

The Elements of Persuasion: Use Storytelling to Pitch Better, Sell Faster & Win More Business by Richard Maxwell and Robert Dickman, banned from Texas prisons, begins with a quote from Harvard University psychologist Howard Gardner:

“Every great leader is a great storyteller.”

The Elements of Persuasion aims to teach readers how to tell stories in order to “have control over [their] own work and ideas.” This book is banned with thousands of others with little explanation,  according to a recent article published by the Austin American-Statesman.

There are many good questions to ask regarding why prisons ban certain books. However, one fact is indisputable: Texas prison authorities clearly believe in the power of books to impact the lives and actions of readers. They acknowledge that belief by disqualifying literature from pop fiction to work by  Nobel Laureates, National Book Award and Pulitzer Prize winners. And, of course, The Elements of Persuasion:

All successful stories have five basic components: the passion with which the story is told, a hero who leads us through the story and allows us to see it through his or her eyes, an antagonist or obstacle that the hero must overcome, a moment of awareness that allows the hero to prevail, and the transformation in the hero and in the world that naturally results.

The components of great stories, as described by Maxwell and Dickman, have unlimited potential to positively impact readers. Does being empowering qualify a book for banning?

The Austin American-Statesman reports that around 5,000 titles have been banned over the last 5 years in Texas prisons. Push by Saphire is on that list; its film version, Precious, just won two Academy Awards (one for Best Adapted Screenplay).

America’s incarcerated are missing out on an overwhelming amount of reading material, acclaimed and otherwise. They’re also being denied the education contained in those books, and this in the country labeled among the world’s highest incarceration rate.

A 2008 New York Times article compared the United States percentage of the world population (less than 5 percent) to the percentage of the world’s prisoners (nearly 25 percent). Despite long and severe prison terms, the U.S. recidivism rate is notoriously high. Most people would probably agree that education plays a significant role in fixing the costly prison system.

Even the U.S. Federal Bureau of Prisons agrees that opportunity is a part of the solution:

The Federal Bureau of Prisons protects society by confining offenders in the controlled environments of prisons and community-based facilities that are safe, humane, cost-efficient, and appropriately secure, and that provide work and other self-improvement opportunities to assist offenders in becoming law-abiding citizens.

Likewise, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice’s mission statement claims an emphasis on positive change:

The mission of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice is to provide public safety, promote positive change in offender behavior, reintegrate offenders into society, and assist victims of crime.

How can prison systems hope to “promote positive change” while restricting access to education?

Robert Dickman and Richard Maxwell comment astutely on the banning of their business book: “If there is one quality you’d think you’d want to improve in prison, it is the ability to communicate clearly and nonviolently. Studies on gang behavior have shown that good communication skills reduce physical violence across the board.”

What do you think? Is there ever a good reason to ban a book? Or are the “elements of persuasion” (and critical thinking, effective communication and problem solving) simply not skills the U.S. prison system would like to promote?

Further reading on Texas’s book ban:


The Guardian.co.uk


3 thoughts on “Over 5,000 Titles Banned from Texas Prisons

  1. Thanks Beth. I cannot think of any reason to ban books. I can think of plenty of good reasons to encourage the reading and writing of good stories though! Keep the vision alive.

  2. That’s very strange! Maybe the prison system doesn’t want prisoners to think their own stories are interesting, or to see themselves as “heroes?” I don’t know – maybe conformity and obedience are threatened by the book. It’s a sad state of affairs when any book is banned. But, thanks Beth, for the link to what sounds like a very interesting read!

  3. I tell you from personal experience this is a real travisty and does grate harm. 99 % of the time a person in the TEXAS penitentry will not be reading anything intelligant. School is a joke and library rights get taken away with security level and restrictions set with recreation rights wich are taken away for anything! Belive me its a cycle that cannot be stopped unless you are VERY carefull…and even then you must have “snitched” on someone to get rid of that case (a diseplinary case). Long story short is books have effects on people and of course ideas are passed on….i think Angela Davis best described the TEXAS DEPARTMET OF CORRECTONS attitude: Jails and prisons are designed to break human beings, to convert the population into specimens in a zoo – obedient to our keepers, but dangerous to each other.
    Angela Davis

Leave a reply! Filling out your name, email, and website is optional.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s